Gaza aid groups continue work amid Israel's ban

Gaza's humanitarian crisis deepens as Israel tightens grip on aid groups.

The Israeli government has banned 37 humanitarian organizations from operating in Gaza, but thousands of staff members are still distributing food and supplies amidst a complete blockade. The ban comes after the government demanded that banned aid groups provide lists of staff members and funding information, despite expressing concern over staff safety. Many have already been killed by Israeli forces while working for these organizations.

Israel has effectively shut down the flow of aid to Gaza, with many hospitals in the territory now operating at just a fraction of capacity. Doctors Without Borders (MSF) is trying to fill this gap, but its efforts are being hindered by the Israeli government's refusal to provide clear answers about the ban.

"We have engaged in the registration process in good faith and made efforts to respond to the requirements communicated to us," said MSF Emergency Coordinator Claire Nicolet. "But we did not receive a response to our requests, and forcing us to leave would deprive hundreds of thousands of people of essential medical care."

The situation in Gaza remains dire, with widespread food shortages, a hollowed-out medical system, and continued airstrikes that have left the territory's inhabitants near completely reliant on outside aid. The ban on humanitarian organizations is seen as an attempt by Israel to choke off the flow of operations while maintaining a veneer of legitimacy.

"Aid getting through is certainly better now than it was in June and July," said one aid worker, who spoke on condition of anonymity. "But we are still far below the norm, and the volume of requests versus the number approved is an indicator that this is not being facilitated well."

As winter sets in and rain pounds Gaza, the risks of respiratory disease are increasing, making the humanitarian crisis even more dire. The bureaucratic management of violence in Israel's war on Gaza is just as deadly as the bombs and tank fire it seems to be avoiding.

The international community has been critical of Israel's actions, with many calling for an end to the blockade and a reversal of the ban on humanitarian organizations. But for those already living in Gaza, the situation remains bleak, and the future looks increasingly uncertain.

you know what's messed up is that aid groups are still managing to get stuff into Gaza despite the Israeli government's best efforts to shut them down... like, i get it, security concerns and all that but come on! thousands of people are literally dying over here and you're still trying to control every little thing? meanwhile msf is out there doing their thing with the bare minimum resources they can scrounge up. its just so frustrating when you think about how much more could be done if governments didn't get in the way all the time...

omg what's going on in gaza?! it's like they're strangling people over there and nobody's doing anything about it... i mean i know israel has its reasons but blocking aid groups is just wrong. thousands of ppl are still getting food and meds despite the ban, so like how is this supposed to help? doctors without borders is literally trying to fill the gap but israel's being super secretive and unhelpful... meanwhile ppl in gaza are literally dying of respiratory problems because of the rain . international community needs to step up and do somethin' more than just talk about it

This is just crazy. They're basically shutting down aid groups but thousands are still out there risking their lives to get food and supplies into Gaza. It's like Israel's all "we care about you" but really they're just messing with people's lives. What's the point of even calling it a blockade if you're not gonna let anything through? MSF is trying to help, but it's like they're playing a game of chicken with the Israeli government. It's getting worse and worse for those living in Gaza, especially as winter sets in...

omg u no how terrible it is 2 see whats goin down in gaza its like they r bein suffocated by israelis strict rules n ban on aid groups but like still these humanitarians r tryin there best 2 help ppl get food n medical supplies its so sad 2 hear about msf staff members bing killed while workin 4 these orgs n now claire nicolet from msf is all like "hey we did our thing but u didnt respond so pls dont kick us out"

i mean i feel for the ppl in gaza who r literally strugglin 2 get by with this blockade n airstrikes its like they re livin in a war zone n i really hope the int'l community does somethin abt dis cuz lets face it aid is flowin but not enuf n the situation is only gonna get worse wen winter hits

I'm literally livin' in a world where some government thinks it can control every single bit of aid that goes into Gaza. Like, come on, don't they get that it's just gonna make things WORSE? They're basically trying to starve ppl and then pretend like they care. I mean, the fact that MSF is having trouble getting info from them is straight fire (). It's not even about the aid itself, it's about the principle. If they can't be bothered to communicate with these orgs, how can we trust they're gonna lift the blockade? It's just a power play and ppl are sufferin'.

this is getting really scary fam...gaza ppl r dying b4 our eyes n no 1's doin enuf

[link to MSF report on Gaza humanitarian crisis](https://www.doctorswithoutborders.org/news/blog/gaza-humanitarian-crisis)

gotta say, it's like israel's tryna choke off aid but still keep lookin all good meanwhile ppl r dyin b4 their eyes

[link to BBC news article on Israeli ban of humanitarian orgs](https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-52281311)

winter's comin & its gettin cold in gaza respiratory disease is gonna be a real problem...we gotta do somethin b4 it gets 2 bad

This whole thing is just so messed up. Like, what even is the point of having aid groups if they can't even operate without being banned by Israel? It's like they're trying to make it harder for people in Gaza to get the help they need. And you know what's crazy? The fact that doctors are still putting themselves in harm's way just so they can try and keep the medical system afloat. I mean, how many more lives have to be lost before something changes? It's not like it's going to fix itself or anything. We need some real action from the international community to make some waves here.

It breaks my heart to see people struggling like that in Gaza. The fact that Israel's grip is tightening on aid groups makes me think about how we're all connected and how one action can have such a ripple effect. I've seen firsthand how even small things, like access to basic supplies, can make a huge difference in someone's life.

What worries me most is the long-term impact this has on Gaza's people. The thought of those hospitals barely functioning and medical staff being killed by Israeli forces sends shivers down my spine. I wish the international community could find more creative solutions to address these issues without escalating tensions.

We need to remember that there are real human lives at stake here, not just statistics or headlines. Let's keep supporting organizations like Doctors Without Borders and try to put ourselves in their shoes – we'd want people to have access to basic necessities too!

Ugh, this is getting super dire for Gazans ... I mean, I get why Israel wants to keep an eye on aid groups, but completely shutting down everything isn't gonna help things . These hospitals are barely operational, and it's like, what even is the point of having a medical system if you're not using it? The docs at MSF are trying so hard, but Israel just won't give them any clear answers... it's all pretty frustrating . And can we talk about how the ban is affecting people's basic human rights? Like, food and water aren't that complicated to provide . It feels like Israel is more worried about looking good than actually helping the people who need help . We should be super critical of this situation, but at the same time, we gotta keep hoping for a better future ... maybe someday things will change and Gaza can start to rebuild

This is a really tough spot for people living in Gaza . The Israeli government's actions are having a massive impact on the humanitarian crisis there, and it's not just about cutting off aid – it's also about controlling the narrative and making it harder for organizations to do their work. I mean, think about it: thousands of staff members who work for these banned organizations are still risking their lives to distribute food and supplies... what kind of "tough stance" is that supposed to represent?

The thing that really gets me is how the international community is stepping in to call out Israel's actions, but it feels like not enough people are actually listening to the stories from Gaza. These aren't just statistics or news headlines – we're talking about real people who are struggling to breathe, who are going hungry, and who are being killed for doing their jobs. It's time for us all to take a closer look at what's really happening in that territory .

Winter is coming, and it's already getting cold in Gaza... the last thing these people need is more suffering due to some bureaucratic quagmire . Can we just try to do better here?

its crazy how israel is suffocating gaza like its a prisoner or somethin the aid groups are still tryin to help but its like theyre walkin through a minefield every time they show up and yall know what? the ppl of gaza dont even get the chance to live their lives rn its all about survivin day by day the internationals r callin out israel but i feel like its not enough they should be doin more than just talkin bout it

this is so messed up like what even is the point of having aid groups if they're just gonna get banned left & right? thousands of people are still struggling to get food & medical care on their own... it's literally heartbreaking and the fact that doctors without borders is getting all this pushback from israel is just ridiculous like, can't they see how much of a difference these aid groups are making? shouldn't we be supporting each other here?

I just think its really unfair that Israel is cracking down on aid groups ... like, we all know they're not doing it to help people or anything . Thousands of staff members are still managing to get food and supplies in there despite the ban, so what's the point of even banning them? It's just gonna drive more people into poverty and suffering . And yeah, doctors without borders is trying to fill the gap, but its not like they're all experts or anything ... I mean, I'm sure MSF is doing a great job, but let's not forget that aid workers are already getting killed by Israeli forces . It's just so messed up .

my heart is breaking thinking about all these innocent ppl stuck in that desperate situation u can imagine how tough it must be to go through daily life without basic necessities like food & water? thousands of aid workers are still risking their lives to help, but the gov's actions just make things worse i mean, can't they see the humanity in all this? these ppl deserve our compassion & support, not some harsh restrictions that only hurt more

this is so messed up i mean what kinda government just cuts off aid to people who are struggling to survive? it's like they're more worried about their own security than helping ppl in need meanwhile there's still all this bureaucracy going on & no clear answers from the gov, it's frustrating. msf is trying to fill the gap but it's not gonna be enough with the gov being so restrictive we gotta do better as a global community to support these ppl

the israeli gov has really taken it too far now . these aid groups are just trying to help ppl in gaza who r struggling 2 survive & they're being banned left & right? that's just not cool mate. i know there gotta be some concern over staff safety but banning the whole org? that's not a solution, dat's just more problems .

and it's even worse when u think about all the ppl who r already dyin in gaza due 2 lack of aid. docs without borders is tryin to fill the gap but they're bein held back by the gov . i feel bad for them, they just wanna help & save lives.

the internationl community should really do somethin about dis . it's not like the israeli gov has done everythin right lately, so can't we just try 2 find some common ground? or at least try 2 make things a little easier 4 these ppl in gaza who r sufferin?

the israeli gov is really stepping up the pressure on aid groups in gaza its like they want to suffocate the ppl with this blockade & ban meanwhile hospitals are barely functioning & docs r working day n night 2 provide help & msf is trying their best but its all being held back by these red tape issues gotta wonder wut kinda "security" measures r really needed 2 justify dis kind of treatment on innocent ppl

ugh, can't believe what's going on in Gaza ... like, I get it, Israel wants control over aid groups, but 37?! That's crazy! And now thousands of staff are still working because they don't want to leave . It's like, the more they try to squeeze out aid, the more people suffer . MSF is trying to fill the gap, but it's all so messed up . How can you expect aid groups to provide lists and info without knowing what's going on?! And Claire Nicolet is right, forcing them to leave will just make things worse . Winter is coming and Gaza needs help now . International community needs to speak up more ... it's not like they're doing nothing .

this is just getting out of control! like, how much more can these ppl be squeezed? 37 orgs banned and still staff are risking their lives to get aid to people who really need it the meds & food don't magically appear from nowhere, you feel? i mean, we all know israel's got its reasons but it's not like anyone's being honest about what those reasons are and now hospitals are basically ghost towns because of this meanwhile int'l community's just kinda...shrugging gotta do more than just condemn the situation, someone's gotta step up & help these ppl