Peace boards and technocrats won’t stem out Palestinian resistance

US-led Plan to Govern Gaza Fails to Address Core Issue of Palestinian Resistance

The United States' latest move to govern the Gaza Strip, a plan that involves appointing technocrats to oversee the territory, has been met with skepticism by Palestinians. The setup reflects Israel's desire to exclude Hamas and the Fatah-dominated Palestinian Authority from any role in governing Gaza, but it fails to acknowledge the deep-seated resistance that defines Palestinian society.

The plan is a prime example of Israeli ignorance about the complexities of Palestinian politics and history. The US-led effort ignores the fact that Palestinians have consistently rejected integration into the Israeli colonial project throughout their national struggle. Over the past 77 years, various Palestinian movements and revolutions have emerged, united by their rejection of Israeli presence in the region.

The use of technocrats to govern Gaza is a farce, as it fails to address the fundamental issue of Palestinian resistance. The Palestinian social fabric naturally rejects any leadership or entity that operates outside the framework of national independence or accepts foreign guardianship. Hamas and Fatah remain the two most prominent political components of Palestinian society, and they share a common commitment to the Palestinian cause and its rights.

Israel's attempts to bypass this reality have been unsuccessful. The country has consistently sought "local alternatives" for governance in Gaza, but these efforts have ended badly. Prominent families and clans have publicly condemned individuals who have collaborated with Israel, withdrawing protection and ostracizing them.

The US plan is doomed to fail because it ignores the legitimacy of Palestinian resistance. In Palestine, legitimacy is derived from resistance, which ties national history and identity together. Any attempt to bypass this reality would only turn Gaza into a zone of permanent chaos, internal conflicts, and comprehensive security collapse.

The only solution that can guarantee stability is full Palestinian administrative independence, based exclusively on the will of the Palestinian people in all their diversity and affiliations, with a clear path toward the establishment of a fully sovereign Palestinian state. Anything less would be a mere spectacle, designed to cover up the fallout of an Israeli-executed genocide.

The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera's editorial stance.

The US-led plan to govern Gaza is just another example of Israel trying to dictate how Palestinians should live their lives . Like, come on, they can't even get it right after 77 years of occupation . The idea that Palestinians are all about accepting foreign guardianship and collaborating with the enemy is so far off . It's like Israel thinks they're some kind of experts on Palestinian politics .

And what's really concerning is how this plan ignores the fact that Hamas and Fatah are still super popular among Palestinians . It's like they think people are just going to magically forget about their resistance and start following some technocrat leader . Newsflash: Palestinians aren't going anywhere, and any attempt to bypass their legitimacy is doomed to fail .

For real, the only way forward is for Palestine to get its independence back . That's the only way we can guarantee stability and peace in the region . Anything less is just a temporary fix that'll eventually blow up in everyone's face . Full admin independence now would be the key !

The US-led plan is like trying to put a square peg into a round hole – it just won't fit. The whole thing is based on ignoring the elephant in the room, which is the Palestinian resistance. I mean, can you blame them for wanting independence and self-governance? It's not like they're asking for the moon here.

The fact that Israel wants to exclude Hamas and Fatah from governing Gaza is just plain laughable. Do they really think they can just push these guys aside and expect everything to magically work out? Newsflash: it won't. The Palestinian people are not some docile, complacent masses who will take whatever the Israeli government throws at them.

And let's be real, the use of technocrats is just a smokescreen. Who do you think these people are supposed to represent, exactly? Not the Palestinian people, that's for sure. It's all about Israel getting its way and maintaining control over the territory. But they're forgetting one very important thing: the Palestinian people will never surrender their resistance.

It's like trying to hold water in your hand – it's just going to slip right through your fingers. The US plan is doomed to fail, and anyone who thinks otherwise is just drinking the Kool-Aid. We need a real solution that takes into account the complexities of Palestinian politics and history, not some half-baked experiment designed to further Israel's interests.

You know what would really guarantee stability? A fully sovereign Palestinian state with complete administrative independence. That's something worth working towards, rather than this tokenistic, feel-good nonsense that the US plan represents.

the whole plan is like they're trying to solve a puzzle with all the pieces missing the US-led effort just ignores the fact that Palestinians have been resisting Israeli control for decades, it's not about governance, it's about self-determination and freedom

i mean, who are these technocrats supposed to be leading? Hamas and Fatah aren't going anywhere, they're the ones with a strong connection to the Palestinian people and their cause

and what's with all this "local alternatives" nonsense? Israel has been trying that for ages, but it just leads to more problems like, have they even considered the cultural and social context of Gaza? It's not just about governance, it's about identity and community

anyway, i think the author hits the nail on the head when they say that legitimacy is derived from resistance in Palestine it's not about accepting foreign guardianship or playing by Israeli rules

I think this US plan is a total joke . It's like they're trying to fit square pegs into round holes, expecting Palestinians to just give up on their resistance. Newsflash: Palestinians won't be silenced or controlled! The fact that Israel is trying to exclude Hamas and Fatah from the equation only makes things worse. It's a classic case of divide and conquer .

I mean, can you imagine if someone tried to govern your community without even asking for your input? Would you just roll over and accept it? I didn't think so . The Palestinian people have a right to self-determination, and that includes the freedom to resist oppression. Full stop.

The US plan is just a Band-Aid on a bullet wound . It's trying to paper over the deep-seated issues in Gaza, but it won't work. You can't just ignore the fact that Palestinians have been resisting Israeli rule for 77 years and expect everything to be okay .

I'm all for stability, but you get what you pay for. If Israel is willing to compromise on its colonial project, then maybe – just maybe – we can find a way forward . But until then, this US plan is nothing more than a waste of time and resources .

this plan is so misguided, like, who do they think can govern Gaza without even understanding the history and culture there? it's all about ignoring the core issue of resistance and just trying to control the situation from above but what's the point if you're not addressing the real problems? 77 years of fighting for independence and they still can't get it right

I dont get why they keep trying to govern Gaza with some fancy tech plan . Palestinians have been fighting for independence 4ever, and it aint gonna change overnight. The resistance is real, and its rooted in their history & culture . Israel needs to accept that Hamas & Fatah are part of the deal, or they need to get outta there altogether . Anythin less just prolongs the conflict & suffering for all parties involved . We should be focusin on findin a peaceful solution that works 4 everyone, not some pie-in-the-sky tech plan .

I'm telling you, it's all about control. Israel wants to keep Gaza under their thumb and they're trying every trick in the book to make sure Hamas and Fatah don't get back in power. But what they're forgetting is that Palestinians aren't just some passive victims - we're a force to be reckoned with! We've been resisting for 77 years, and we won't stop until we have our own state. This whole "technocrat" thing is just a weak attempt to undermine our legitimacy. Newsflash: it's not gonna work. The only way forward is true independence and self-governance - that's the only way we'll ever be able to build a stable future for ourselves and our people.

I'm so tired of these new plans from the US and Israel... it feels like they're just ignoring all the Palestinian people want . They keep trying to bypass Hamas and Fatah, but honestly, those two are the only ones who really care about the Palestinian cause . And what's with this "technocrat" nonsense? It's just a fancy way of saying they're not in control of their own lives or their own territory . We need real change, like full independence for Palestine, period . Any less than that is just going to lead to more conflict and suffering . Can't we all just get along?

its gonna take more than just some technocrats to fix gaza's problems they need to talk to the people on the ground, listen to their concerns and work with them to find a solution that actually benefits everyone not just israel full admin independence for palestine is the only way forward imo

I mean, come on! The US just tried to ram their plan down Palestinians' throats like they're some kinda colonial experiment gone wrong . Newsflash: Gaza's been living under Israeli occupation for decades, and the resistance is legit . Can't they see that their "technocrat" plan is just a fancy way of saying "we're gonna control everything"? The Palestinians have had enough of being treated like subjects instead of equals . They need to take ownership of their own governance and not rely on some foreign puppet master . And btw, what's with all the talk about Hamas and Fatah? Can't they just get along for once?

I just don't get why Israel is still trying to control Gaza like that . It feels like they're just ignoring the fact that Palestinians want their independence, you know? Like, it's been 77 years and stuff has only gotten more complicated. I think this new plan by the US is a joke, because who do these technocrats even represent? The people of Gaza or Israel? And what about Hamas and Fatah? They're like the two main players in Palestinian politics, so why are they being excluded from the decision-making process? It just seems like Israel's trying to mess with the situation again and it's never gonna work out.

Gaza situation is so messed up . US plan just tries to sweep everything under rug . Palestinians have been resisting for 77 years , can't ignore it . Technocrats can't lead resistance movement , need real Palestinian leadership . Israel's tried before to bypass reality , failed miserably . US plan doomed from start . Gaza needs independence, not foreign control . Palestinians deserve self-governance, not some watered-down version . We need stability, but at what cost?

honestly i dont get why ppl think technocrats can govern a place thats all about resistance & identity? its like tryna fit square pegs into round holes theyd just end up being pawns 4 israel anyway what works in palestine isnt about governance or tech, its about the ppl themselves, their culture, their history

The US plan is like trying to hold water in your hands - it just keeps slipping away . Israel needs to acknowledge that Palestinians aren't going to just accept a technocratic government set up by them. It's like they think the 77 years of Palestinian resistance and protests have just gone unnoticed . Newsflash: we haven't forgotten about our history, our struggles, and our desire for independence . The Gaza Strip is already a disaster zone, and any new plan that ignores these fundamental issues will only make things worse . Full administrative independence with the Palestinian people in charge - now that's something worth exploring

the us-led plan is just another example of how out of touch they are with palestinian society . technocrats can't replace the real leaders who have been fighting for their rights all these years, like hamas and fatah. it's not about governance, it's about respecting the will of the people . if israel really wants stability, they should focus on finding a solution that acknowledges palestinian resistance . any less would just be a Band-Aid solution at best .

the US plan is so naive Gaza has been under occupation for over 77 years and resistance has become a huge part of palestinian identity, its hard to imagine anyone in gaza wanting foreign control the whole point of having technocrats is to bypass the real issues like human rights abuses and inequality

Gaza is such a mess ... I just don't get why the US is trying to govern it like that. They're gonna push more people against the wall, ya know? It's all about power struggles & who gets to control the narrative. But honestly, they're barking up the wrong tree if they think Palestinian resistance can be just 'tamed' with some techies in charge ... Gaza needs autonomy, not handouts .

The US plan is like trying to put a Band-Aid on a wound that won't heal - it just keeps covering up the same issues! They think they can just hand-pick technocrats to govern Gaza without addressing the root cause of resistance? Please, Palestinians aren't going to accept some new leaders who are beholden to Israel. It's like they're trying to erase Palestinian identity and history. What Israel needs to do is sit down with Palestinians and figure out a way to make peace that actually works for everyone involved. Otherwise, we'll just keep seeing the same cycle of violence and chaos repeat itself.

lol what a joke this plan is 70+ yrs & they still cant get it right? its all about control & exclusion, not about helping ppl these technocrats r just gonna be puppets on strings anyway gotta give credit tho, its entertaining to watch the us try lol and btw whats with all this talk of stability & security? yall havent seen the occupation's track record on that front full independence is the only way forward