NFL leaders are pushing back against a viral conspiracy theory that suggests the San Francisco 49ers' recent injury woes are linked to electromagnetic fields from a nearby electrical substation.
The claim, which has resurfaced on social media and at the Super Bowl press conference, posits that exposure to EMFs could be causing players like 49ers quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo to suffer from chronic pain and inflammation. However, medical experts have widely debunked this theory, with the NFL's chief medical officer dismissing it as "baseless" last week.
The 49ers' owner Jed York also chimed in on the issue during an appearance on a radio show, noting that the substation has been near the team's facilities for decades and has not been linked to any problems. "Jerry Rice was there," York said. "It didn't seem to affect Jerry Rice. It seems like Jerry Rice can still play today. I don't think that's something that's a real issue."
Sports medicine specialists say there is no clear connection between electrical infrastructure and injury rates, with Dr. Drew Lansdown, a sports medicine surgeon at UCSF, stating it is "hard to draw that connection" from the substation to what has been seen on the field.
However, Lansdown acknowledged that league leaders and medical experts should acknowledge public concerns rather than dismissing them outright. "I think it is important to acknowledge that they have looked into it," he said. "To understand if there is something that could be done differently. I think the worst thing would be to ignore it."
The NFL Players Association has also pushed back on the theory, with interim executive director David White stating that medical experts have found no evidence supporting the claim. While curiosity around the theory is not surprising, White emphasized the need for credible data.
For now, it seems that the 49ers and the rest of the league will continue to play without worrying about EMFs from nearby substations contributing to their injuries. But as Lansdown pointed out, it's always better to acknowledge concerns rather than dismiss them outright.
The claim, which has resurfaced on social media and at the Super Bowl press conference, posits that exposure to EMFs could be causing players like 49ers quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo to suffer from chronic pain and inflammation. However, medical experts have widely debunked this theory, with the NFL's chief medical officer dismissing it as "baseless" last week.
The 49ers' owner Jed York also chimed in on the issue during an appearance on a radio show, noting that the substation has been near the team's facilities for decades and has not been linked to any problems. "Jerry Rice was there," York said. "It didn't seem to affect Jerry Rice. It seems like Jerry Rice can still play today. I don't think that's something that's a real issue."
Sports medicine specialists say there is no clear connection between electrical infrastructure and injury rates, with Dr. Drew Lansdown, a sports medicine surgeon at UCSF, stating it is "hard to draw that connection" from the substation to what has been seen on the field.
However, Lansdown acknowledged that league leaders and medical experts should acknowledge public concerns rather than dismissing them outright. "I think it is important to acknowledge that they have looked into it," he said. "To understand if there is something that could be done differently. I think the worst thing would be to ignore it."
The NFL Players Association has also pushed back on the theory, with interim executive director David White stating that medical experts have found no evidence supporting the claim. While curiosity around the theory is not surprising, White emphasized the need for credible data.
For now, it seems that the 49ers and the rest of the league will continue to play without worrying about EMFs from nearby substations contributing to their injuries. But as Lansdown pointed out, it's always better to acknowledge concerns rather than dismiss them outright.