Only Europe can save Ukraine from Putin and Trump – but will it? | Timothy Garton Ash

Europe's Fate Hangs in the Balance as it Faces Off Against Putin's Russia

In a dramatic and precarious situation, Europe finds itself squarely on the defensive against Vladimir Putin's Russia. The European Union's collective resolve is being tested like never before, with the fate of Ukraine hanging precariously in the balance.

The warning signs have been there for some time – from the initial invasion of Crimea in 2014 to the ongoing war in eastern Ukraine. But it wasn't until recently that the full weight of Putin's aggression became clear. The Russian president has made no secret of his ambitions, and his latest threat – that Russia is "ready right now" for war with Europe if need be – should serve as a stark reminder of the gravity of the situation.

Meanwhile, in the United States, President Donald Trump has demonstrated an alarming lack of commitment to defending Ukraine. His new National Security Strategy openly advocates for cultivating resistance to European unity within European nations, effectively pitting the US against its allies on this critical issue.

So, how can Europe hope to save Ukraine from the clutches of Putin's Russia? The answer lies in a combination of military and economic support, as well as diplomatic pressure. By mobilizing their combined economy and defense production, Europeans can provide Ukraine with the necessary resources to counter Russian aggression. Moreover, by stopping and rigorously inspecting shadow fleet ships that transport seaborne oil exports through Danish straits, Europe can exert significant economic pressure on Russia.

Ukraine itself has a crucial role to play in this drama. With the departure of its president's right-hand man Andriy Yermak, there is an opportunity for Ukraine to make a bold domestic reset and establish a government of national unity. This could be a game-changer, as it would demonstrate a commitment to unity and stability at home that would serve as a powerful counterweight to Russian influence abroad.

However, Europe faces two major challenges in its efforts to support Ukraine. First, there is the question of whether Europe can collectively muster sufficient military and economic power to overcome Russian resistance. The still pervasive myth of Russian invincibility, combined with the procedural slowness of EU institutions, as well as acute competition for public money between European states, all pose significant hurdles.

Second, there is the issue of national egoism, which has led some European leaders to prioritize short-term interests over long-term collective security. The recent squabble between France and Germany over a joint project for a next-generation fighter jet is just one example of this problem.

Despite these challenges, there remains a glimmer of hope. For if Europe can summon the courage to put the long-term collective interest before party-political opportunity, it may yet emerge victorious in this struggle. As historian Timothy Garton Ash so eloquently puts it, "Europe will" – but only if we will it.

Ultimately, the fate of Ukraine and the future of European unity hang precariously in the balance. The outcome is far from certain, but one thing is clear: Europe must rise to this major challenge, no matter how daunting it may seem. For if we do not, the consequences for our continent, our allies, and the world at large could be catastrophic.

The question on everyone's lips is: will Europe find the strength, resolve, and determination necessary to save Ukraine from Putin's Russia? The answer remains uncertain – but one thing is clear: only time will tell.
 
🤔 what's going on with europe's defense strategy? like they're just gonna let russia walk all over them? 🚫 i mean, trump's new security strategy is straight up scary - basically saying europe needs to fight among themselves instead of standing together against russia. how can that possibly work out for anyone? 💔

also, andriy yermak's departure from ukraine's gov't is a big deal... but aren't the eu states supposed to be providing some kinda economic aid or military support to ukraine already? what's the holdup on that? 🤓

and can we talk about how all these diplomats are just sitting around twiddling their thumbs while russia does whatever it wants? like, where's the plan? 💡
 
can u believe this guy trump saying he dont wanna defend ukraine lol like what r they even doin over there ? 🤦‍♂️ europe needs 2 step up their game ASAP 💪 and btw why cant they just get along already? 🙄 its like they're tryin 2 stab each other in the back 😂
 
Wow 🤯 - it's like Europe is holding its breath right now. I mean, Putin's been making some serious moves and now the whole continent's feeling the pressure. The US not being super supportive of Ukraine is crazy talk too 😂. But seriously, how can Europe just sit back and let Russia do whatever it wants? It's gotta put its money where its mouth is 💸, you know? Military support, economic aid - something's gotta give here. And I love the idea of Ukraine making a domestic reset to show everyone that they're not gonna take this lying down 🤜🤛
 
🤔 Europe is literally walking into a war with Russia 🚨😬 and I'm not sure if it's gonna work out in their favor... They need to put aside their differences and work together, like, now 💼. Trump's comments on Ukraine are super concerning too 🙅‍♂️ - what kinda ally does that? 😒

But at the same time, I get why they can't just sit back and do nothing 🤷‍♀️. Russia is a major threat to Europe's security and stability ⚔️. And Ukraine needs their support ASAP 🕰️.

The economic pressure tactic could be pretty effective 💸, if executed properly. And if Ukraine can just get its act together domestically 🏛️, it might make them harder for Russia to manipulate 🤥.

Still, I'm not holding my breath... Europe's got some big hurdles to jump over 🚧, and the ego thing is a major obstacle 🙄. Will they be able to put aside their differences and work towards a common goal? Only time will tell ⏰.
 
I'm getting a bad feeling about this whole situation 🤕. I mean, I know we've been saying for years that the EU needs to be more united and stuff, but now it feels like we're finally facing a real crisis and Europe is just kinda... meh? 😐 Like, what's the plan here? Are we gonna put our money where our mouth is or are we just gonna sit back and wait for Russia to invade us? 🤯 I know we've got some amazing military tech and all, but let's be real, Putin's got some serious firepower too 💥. And don't even get me started on the economic part – if Europe doesn't put some serious pressure on Russia, they're just gonna keep on exploiting our markets and stuff. 🤑 It's time for us to step up our game and show Putin that we mean business 💪. We can do this, EU! ⚠️
 
I'm so confused about this whole thing with Ukraine 🤔... like what even is going on? Is it like a big war or something? And who's Putin again? 😕 I thought he was that guy from Russia in the movies, not a real person 🎬. So how can Europe help Ukraine if they don't have any money 💸? Can't they just print more money or something? 🤑
 
europe needs to step up its game 🤔🚀 if they wanna support ukraine against putin's russa. it's not just about military power tho, they need to get their act together on the economic front too 💸📈 like, how can they expect to help ukraine when they cant even agree on basic things themselves? 🤷‍♀️ and whats with all this national egoism crap? france and germany fighting over a fighter jet? come on 🚫💥

anywayz, i think europe has the potential to save ukraine but they need to put aside their differences and work together 💪🏽🌎. it's like, we're all in this together, right? 🤝 so lets hope europe can summon the courage to do what needs to be done 🙏💕
 
🤔 I'm just not convinced about this whole "Europe will" thing. Like, what exactly does that even mean? Is it just a historical precedent or something? Did Europe really just magically come together in the past and solve all its problems? 🤷‍♂️

And what's with all these experts saying that Ukraine needs to do some domestic reset to counter Russian influence? That sounds like a lot of empty promises. What concrete steps is Ukraine even supposed to take? And how are we going to know when it's done? 💸

Not to mention, Europe's own problems with national egoism and bureaucratic red tape are already holding them back. I mean, come on, can't they just agree on something for once without all the squabbling? 🙄

I'm not saying I don't believe in European unity or anything, but let's not get too caught up in this "will" nonsense. We need some real substance and concrete actions from our leaders before we start expecting miracles. 💪
 
I'm really worried about what's happening in Ukraine 🤕💔 Russia's actions are so unpredictable and it feels like no one knows what the next move is going to be. I mean, President Trump's new strategy towards Europe just makes things more complicated 🤯. We need to stand together as a continent and support Ukraine in any way we can 🇺🇦💪

I think if European countries could put aside their differences and focus on the bigger picture, they'd be able to come up with a much stronger plan to help Ukraine 💡. And yeah, it's crazy that there are still so many people who don't believe in Russian invincibility 😂. We can do this!
 
🤔 "The die has been cast." - Julius Caesar 💀💥 I think it's too late for Europe to change course now that the situation with Putin's Russia has escalated so dramatically 🕰️. The US, EU, and other allies need to be more united in their response to this threat than they have been so far 👊. We can't just sit back and wait for the worst-case scenario to unfold – we need to take action NOW 💪!
 
I'm getting a bit worried about this whole situation 🤔... I mean, have you seen the latest news on the conflict in eastern Europe? It's like Russia just keeps pushing and pushing without any signs of backing down 😬. And what's even more worrying is that some EU leaders seem more interested in protecting their own national interests than standing up to Putin. It's like they're playing into his hands 🙅‍♂️.

I think we need to see some real commitment from Europe and its leaders if we want to support Ukraine and stand up to Russia. We can't just sit back and watch as our continent becomes divided over this issue 🤦‍♀️. We need to rally behind a unified front and show Putin that we won't be intimidated.

It's also worrying that some of our own politicians, like Trump, seem more interested in weakening Europe than strengthening it 💸. That's not leadership, that's just politics as usual 😒.
 
omg have u ever tried those new matcha flavored chips from japan?? i swear they're like a game changer 🤩💥 u just need that kinda energy when ur dealing with world politics lol but for real tho, its crazy how some european leaders are more worried about their own egos than the bigger picture 🙄🇫🇷🇩🇪 what's the point of having a united europe if they can't even work together on something like this?? 🤷‍♀️ anyway, back to those matcha chips - u gotta try them with a cuppa ☕
 
man 🤯 i think eu is being way too cautious here theyre all worried about their own economies and national interests instead of putting their foot down and saying no to putin's aggression we need to show some backbone and solidarity with ukraine ASAP 🌟
 
😬 this whole situation with Putin is super worrying, i mean europe gotta step up their game if they wanna support ukraine, can't just sit back & wait for russia to do somethin 🤦‍♂️ and btw what's goin on w/ trump? 😒 his national security strategy is like, super concerning 🚨 anyway, think europe should work together more, share resources & def production would be a huge help 4 ukraine 💪
 
I'm getting a bad feeling about this whole situation 🤕. I mean, Europe needs to step up its game and show Putin that he can't just bully them around anymore 😤. It's not just Ukraine that's at stake, but the entire European way of life.

I don't get why some EU leaders are still playing politics instead of putting the country first 🙄. And what's with this whole "Russian invincibility" thing? That's just a bunch of nonsense 💁‍♀️. Europe needs to wake up and realize that it's not weak, but strong and united when it stands together 💪.

And let's be real, President Trump's new National Security Strategy is a total disaster 🤦‍♂️. The US should be supporting Ukraine, not undermining European unity 🚫. It's time for the EU to take matters into its own hands and show Putin that they're not going to back down without a fight 🔥.

I'm still holding out hope that Europe will find the strength and determination to save Ukraine from Russia's clutches 💕. We just need to stick together, support each other, and show the world what we're capable of 💪. It's time for Europe to rise up and take back control 🙌!
 
Back
Top