CDC vaccine panel realizes again it has no idea what it’s doing, delays big vote

"Vaccine Panel Realizes It's in Over Its Head, Delays Crucial Vote"

A chaotic meeting of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) vaccine panel has left experts stunned after the committee realized it had no idea what it was doing. The decision to delay a crucial vote on the recommended dose of the hepatitis B vaccine for newborns comes as a surprise, given that the panel was hand-picked by anti-vaccine Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

The meeting was marked by disorganization and confusion, with members struggling to understand the topic at hand. Anti-vaccine activists took center stage, delivering presentations that were riddled with false claims and conspiracy theories. The committee's own data presentations were also marred by errors and misrepresentations, leaving many to wonder how such a critical decision could be made without proper scientific rigor.

One of the most egregious examples of this came from Cynthia Nevison, an anti-vaccine activist who presented on hepatitis B transmission rates. Despite having no medical background, she claimed that the dramatic decline in hepatitis B infections following vaccination efforts was not actually due to the vaccine. Her claims were quickly debunked by pediatrician Amy Middleman, who pointed out that her presentation was based on a misunderstanding of a key study.

The meeting also saw the introduction of Mark Blaxill, an anti-vaccine activist with no background in medicine or science. He presented on hepatitis B vaccine safety, despite having written books and articles falsely claiming that vaccines cause a variety of harms in children.

As the meeting descended into chaos, medical experts were left to pick up the pieces. "This is completely inappropriate," said Jason Goldman, an ACIP liaison representing the American College of Physicians. "We need to use evidence-based frameworks to make recommendations, not cherry-pick data and ignore the process."

The committee will reconvene tomorrow for a second day of deliberations, but it remains to be seen whether they will be able to come to a decision on the hepatitis B vaccine. One thing is clear, however: the meeting has highlighted the need for greater scientific rigor and expertise in shaping vaccine policy.

Meanwhile, Health Secretary Kennedy Jr.'s role in selecting the panel has raised eyebrows among experts. "It's like handing a committee of novice amateur sleuths a pair of binoculars and telling them to start hunting for clues," said one expert. The consequences of this approach are being felt already, with critical vaccine recommendations hanging in the balance.

omg can you even imagine having a panel of experts decide on vaccine policy without any actual science backing it up they're basically winging it and it's so not cool i mean, what even is going on here? they had an anti-vax activist presenting like she was some kind of medical genius and then the pediatrician just fact-checks her all over the place it's just so frustrating when you think about how much lives are at stake here

I'm shocked ! You gotta wonder how they ended up like that . I mean, what's next? They gonna handpick a committee to decide on climate change denial too? Anyway, it's not just about the panel, it's about the whole vaccine process. We need experts in their fields making decisions, not just some folks with an opinion .

And can we talk about Robert F Kennedy Jr.? What was he thinking?! Handpicking a panel of anti-vaxxers? That's like putting a fox in charge of the henhouse . I remember when vaccines were first introduced, they were so effective! Now it's all about "debating" and "science"... please .

And have you seen these activists? Cynthia Nevison and Mark Blaxill? They're like a couple of clown doctors trying to make medicine . It's not just about the science; it's about lives at stake .

This whole thing is just so... ugh . We need more transparency, more evidence-based decision making, and less "experts" with an agenda . Can't we get it together?

omg have u heard about the CDC vaccine panel meeting? they're literally struggling 2 make a decision on a crucial vaccine it's like they have no idea what they're doing and then there r these anti-vaccine activists who just spew conspiracy theories & false claims it's so weird how they got picked by Health Secretary Kennedy Jr. I mean, does he even know what he's doing? is this some kinda joke?

just saw this news about the CDC vaccine panel meeting and I'm like totally shook lol they're literally clueless i mean what even is a health sec that's supposed to pick a bunch of experts but ends up choosing activists who have no idea what they're talking about it's like they're trying to make a decision based on misinformation and conspiracy theories I'm all for transparency but come on guys get the facts straight before you start making decisions that could affect people's lives

Ugh this is crazy! how can a bunch of ppl with no medical background just waltz into a meeting supposed to make life or death decisions about vaccines? what's going on over there?! i need some solid sources on this before i even think about forming an opinion, but from what i'm seeing it looks like a total disaster. who is gonna hold these ppl accountable for their actions?

the whole situation is pretty wild , i mean, you'd think that a group of experts tasked with making life-or-death decisions would have their act together by now. but nope, it seems like they're just winging it and hoping for the best. the fact that anti-vaxxers got to present at the meeting is just laughable - i mean, what's next? inviting climate change deniers to talk about global warming?

and don't even get me started on the errors and misrepresentations that were presented as "data" - it's like they took a bunch of conspiracy theories, threw them in a blender, and hit puree. i'm not sure what's more concerning, the fact that these people are trying to make decisions about public health or that they're being taken seriously by their peers.

the whole thing just feels like a mess, and it's going to take some serious cleaning up before we can even think about making any recommendations. and let's not forget that Robert F Kennedy Jr is behind all this - what does he know about science?

I'm really surprised that the vaccine panel is struggling like this! You'd think they'd have it all figured out after all the years of research and testing on vaccines . But at the same time, I get why they're pushing back - we can't just ignore the anti-vax crowd, but some of these conspiracy theorists are straight-up crazy . I mean, Cynthia Nevison's presentation about hepatitis B transmission rates was like something out of a bad movie ! And Mark Blaxill showing up without any medical background is just wild... like what even is he doing on this committee?!

just when u think vaccines r done deal, it hits u that some ppl r more clueless than a box of rocks CDC panel is all like "huh? what r we doin? " & then they got anti-vaxxers runnin' amok with fake info ... how's that supposed to work out in the end?

I don't think it's fair to say that the CDC vaccine panel is in over its head just because they had a chaotic meeting. I mean, come on, Health Secretary Kennedy Jr.'s team picked some pretty unconventional experts to be on the panel... and yeah, things got a bit messy. But you can't blame the whole panel for the actions of one or two individuals who might not have done their due diligence. Let's give them a chance to get it together and make some informed decisions about vaccine policy. And hey, maybe this is just an opportunity for the CDC to take a closer look at its processes and improve its communication with experts in the field?

Ugh man, this is getting out of hand ... I mean, how can you put experts who have no medical background on a committee that's supposed to make life or death decisions about vaccines? It's like they're playing politics with people's lives over here. The fact that Robert F. Kennedy Jr. picked these folks is just nuts . And now we've got Cynthia Nevison spreading conspiracy theories about hepatitis B transmission rates... it's a joke . I'm all for open discussion, but not when it comes at the expense of science and critical thinking. This is exactly why we need more transparency and accountability in government, like actually having experts with expertise on these panels . We can't just hand over the reins to amateur sleuths who know nothing about vaccines... that's a recipe for disaster .

I'm totally freaking out about this , can't believe those anti-vaccine activists just took over a meeting meant for experts to decide on vaccine policy . What's even more wild is that Health Secretary Kennedy Jr.'s handpicked panel has no idea what they're doing . It's like throwing a bunch of fish into a pool and expecting them all to swim in the same direction .

We need real medical experts making decisions, not people who think vaccines are toxic or whatever . I mean, Cynthia Nevison and Mark Blaxill? Come on! They're spreading misinformation like wildfire . The American College of Physicians guy is right, though - we need to base our recommendations on actual science, not cherry-picked data .

The whole thing just feels so... chaotic . Can't they just get it together and make a decision already? The hepatitis B vaccine is crucial for newborns, and now it's all getting held up by this anti-vaccine nonsense . It's like watching a train wreck in slow motion - you know it's gonna end badly .

omg u guys can u believe what just went down? the cdc vaccine panel is literally clueless about vaccines lol i mean i know there's a lot of misinformation out there but come on. it's not like they're even trying to be objective or anything. and what's up with health secretary robert f kennedy jr picking a whole committee of anti-vaxxers? that's just crazy talk. anyways, i'm low-key worried about the delay in voting on the new vaccine dose... fingers crossed it gets resolved soon

‍ this meeting was a total mess like how do experts even make decisions without proper info ? and what's up with these anti-vaccine activists getting all legit on us they're spreading false info left & right ... one of them even claimed the vaccine wasn't working meanwhile, medical experts are like "wait, what?"

This CDC meeting is a total disaster! They're trying to make decisions on vaccines with a bunch of anti-vaccine activists who have no idea what they're talking about . I mean, come on, Cynthia Nevison has no medical background and she's presenting on hepatitis B transmission rates? It's like handing someone a microscope and telling them to operate without any training . And what's with Mark Blaxill's "expertise"? He's been writing books saying vaccines cause harm, but he has no medical expertise to back it up . This whole thing is just chaotic and unprofessional . I hope they can get their act together soon and make some sense of this...

omg can u believe dis? so the vaccine panel is like totally lost they got no idea what they're doing and it's all because that Health Secretary dude chose them it's crazy how anti-vax activists got to present and just spewed out lies like who cares about science here? anyway, hopefully they figure it out tomorrow but I'm low-key worried

I don't even know how we're supposed to trust these guys anymore . I mean, come on, you get an entire committee of vaccine experts and they can't even figure out what they're doing? It's like they're just making it up as they go along. And with some of the people they've got on that panel, I'm surprised they didn't bring in some flat earthers or climate change deniers to spice things up . I don't get why we need anti-vaxxers on a committee about vaccines anyway? It's like putting a fox in charge of the henhouse . This whole thing is just a mess, and I'm not sure how they're going to come out with any credible recommendations from this bunch .

this is so worrying , what's going on with these anti-vaxxers taking over the CDC vaccine panel? i mean, come on, you can't just let someone with no medical background be giving out info on vaccine safety and transmission rates. it's like they're trying to confuse people on purpose .

i feel for the medical experts who are trying to do their job with all this chaos around them . and what's with Health Secretary Kennedy Jr.'s role in selecting the panel? shouldn't he be focusing on getting vaccines out to people instead of playing politics?

anyway, i hope they get it together soon and make some sensible decisions about vaccine policy . we need experts like Jason Goldman who are actually knowledgeable about the subject to be guiding the committee.

this whole thing is just a nightmare ...

I just saw the funniest video of a cat playing the piano online . I mean, it's like the cat is totally vibing with the music or something! Anyway, back to vaccines... I was thinking, have you guys ever noticed how some people's opinions on vaccines are always influenced by what they see on YouTube? Like, don't get me wrong, some YouTubers do their research and provide valuable info, but others just spread misinformation like it's going out of style . Anyway, enough about that... did you know that the cat playing piano video is over 10 million views now?