Would Notre Dame or Miami be favored in hypothetical rematch? We asked the oddsmakers

Would Notre Dame or Miami be favored in hypothetical rematch? We asked the oddsmakers' and it appears that the two playoff hopefuls have divergent opinions.

Oddsmaker Chris Andrews from Las Vegas believes that Notre Dame is the better team, with the Irish receiving a three-point advantage over Miami. "The talent level is equal," he said, "but Miami is too inconsistent and a huge coaching advantage [goes to] Notre Dame." This stance aligns with the notion that the first matchup was an anomaly rather than a true representation of the teams' abilities.

On the other hand, Adam Burns from offshore outfit BetOnline.ag sees it as more of a 50-50 proposition on neutral ground. "That [first] game was in Miami and a long time ago," he said. "On a neutral field, this is close to a 50/50 game, but I would lean Irish as a small favorite." This differing assessment reflects the perceived impact of the coaching advantage that Notre Dame has over Miami.

Ultimately, it is uncertain which team would emerge victorious in a hypothetical rematch between Notre Dame and Miami.

OMG u guys I'm still reeling from that 1st game btw what's up with that crazy comeback by Miami lol they def had some good momentum going but idk if they can keep it up, i mean notre dame is just so deep on both sides of the ball and their coaching staff is legit, i mean they're all about that discipline life . on the other hand miami's got some talent for sure but like Adam said, consistency is key if u can't even count on yurself every week then ur gonna get exposed . i'm leaning towards notre dame as a small fave 4 this one too lol

I think Notre Dame's coach must be doing something right . I mean, Miami got dominated the first time around and now they're saying the game is 50/50? Come on... . Notre Dame's defense was all over Miami in that one. I'm surprised they didn't give them more of a spread considering their coaching advantage . But at the same time, you never know what can happen in sports. Maybe Miami just needs to figure out who's really leading the team and then they might have a shot .

I gotta say, if I was betting on this one... I'd put my money on Notre Dame, but only by like 2 points max . I mean, the first game was definitely an anomaly, what with the crazy weather conditions and all that jazz . But now that they've got more reps under their belt, I think Miami's gonna be able to bring it a bit more consistently . Plus, Notre Dame's coaching advantage is real, you feel me?

I think Notre Dame is gonna crush it this time around. They got some awesome talent but I'm really worried about Miami's inconsistency they just can't seem to get it together sometimes . Plus, that coaching advantage is huge for ND. Adam from BetOnline.ag might be right though 50-50 on neutral ground sounds about right , but I'm gonna go with Irish all the way

I'm loving this rematch talk , but have you guys noticed how the odds are all over the place? Like, I get what Adam says about it being 50/50 on neutral ground, but I still think ND's coaching advantage is a big deal . Chris Andrews makes some solid points too tho, about Miami's inconsistency. But at the end of the day, I don't know who'd win in a rematch... maybe we'll just have to wait and see .

Also, can we talk about how ugly the odds layout is on this website? It's like they're not even trying to make it visually appealing . Give me a grid with some color, maybe some icons or something. I mean, I know it's not all about looks, but come on... .

By the way, who's favored in the playoff right now?

Can you imagine the trash talk between the two coaches after this one? "Hey coach, I heard you cried to the refs during the last game" meanwhile on the other side, Coach Leach is all like " Nah fam, we just had a bad day" But for real though, it's gonna be a tough call. If Notre Dame is 3 points up, that means Miami has gotta score way more than they did in the last game (or like 20 points) to even get a chance... but on the other hand, if it's 50/50, then both teams have a good shot at winning Either way, I'm rooting for the underdog... aka my fantasy football squad

Just thinkin' about this matchup and I'm gettin' anxious . If they're gonna play again, can't we just get some answers? Not sure what's more frustrating - the unknown or the fact that coaches are carryin' way too much weight in these decisions .

Wow , can't believe how divided the oddsmakers are on this one! Interesting , I think it's crazy to rely so much on coaching advantage when you have two teams with top-notch talent like this . Miami's inconsistency is a major concern, but Notre Dame's team chemistry is something special . This rematch is gonna be EPIC , whoever wins will prove they're the real deal !

I'm so confused about this rematch! So, oddsmakers think Notre Dame is better than Miami, but Adam from BetOnline.ag thinks they're evenly matched? What's the difference between those two teams that's making people lean towards one side or the other? Is it just because of that coaching advantage I hear about? And what happened in the first game anyway? Was it really as bad for Miami as everyone says?

I'm still trying to wrap my head around the fact that one game can totally flip teams' reputations like that . I mean, if Notre Dame was actually supposed to be the underdog, why are they getting favored now? It just doesn't add up. And what's with this whole "coaching advantage" thing? Like, can we just focus on the actual game instead of making assumptions about coaches' skills?

And can we talk about how the odds keep changing depending on who you ask? It's like everyone has their own opinion and they're all kinda right. I mean, it's not like there's some concrete evidence to back up one team or the other. It's just speculation at this point.

I think it's crazy how much of a difference coaching makes , I mean like in school we have our teachers who are all about that student success life , but when it comes to the pros, having a head coach with experience can really make a big difference . Like Notre Dame's Coach Kelly has been around the block a few times and has some impressive wins under his belt , whereas Miami's coaching staff is still finding their footing . It's defo not an easy matchup to call, but I'd say if anyone wants to put my money on it, I'm gonna go with Notre Dame !

I'm still not sure why teams can't agree on what they want to achieve ... 3 points for ND? That's wild. I mean, if Miami is as bad at home as the first game showed, maybe they should just own it and say "hey we're gonna lose here and just focus on other games"? On the other hand, if ND is that much better coached, wouldn't it be worth giving them a boost? At the end of the day though, I love watching these rematches because you never know what's gonna happen

I think it's so cool how both oddsmakers have different takes on this hypothetical game . I mean, Chris Andrews thinks Notre Dame has the edge just because of that coaching advantage . But Adam Burns is like "hey, let's not forget what happened in the first game" . For me, it's all about how each team responds to pressure now . If Miami can iron out those inconsistencies and get more consistent, they've got this . And if Notre Dame keeps that momentum going... yeah, I think they're gonna come out on top

I think people are underestimating Miami's potential. They've been making huge strides and have some amazing players on their roster . And you know what? I love how the coaches bring different approaches to the game. It's like they're trying to outsmart each other, and that's where the real magic happens. Notre Dame might have that extra edge with coaching, but Miami's got heart . If they can just get it together, who knows, maybe they'll pull off a stunning upset .

I'm thinking if Miami can just get their offense going on a consistent basis they might have a shot at beating Notre Dame . But it's hard to argue with the coaching advantage that Notre Dame has over Miami, especially since it seems like Notre Dame is able to execute better under pressure. I mean, if Miami can't take care of business in a big game on their home turf, how will they do against a coach who knows them so well?