The Supreme Court takes up the most unconstitutional thing Trump has done

The Supreme Court has agreed to take up a case that could potentially strip millions of Americans of their birthright citizenship. The move comes after President Donald Trump issued an executive order in January 2021 attempting to remove citizenship from certain newborn Americans born to undocumented mothers whose fathers are not citizens or lawful permanent residents.

The issue at hand is whether the Constitution allows for such denationalization, and if not, why Trump's attempt to do so was unconstitutional. Critics argue that the Fourteenth Amendment guarantees birthright citizenship to all persons born in the United States, regardless of their parents' immigration status.

One key provision of the amendment states that "all persons born or naturalized in the United States...are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside." This language has been interpreted by courts to mean that anyone born in the US is a citizen, as long as they are subject to the jurisdiction of the country.

However, Trump's lawyers have argued that the Fourteenth Amendment only applies to individuals who owe "direct and immediate allegiance" to the nation. They claim that this means children whose parents are undocumented immigrants do not meet the criteria for citizenship.

This argument is dubious at best, as the words "completely subject" and "political jurisdiction" do not appear in the original text of the amendment. Trump's lawyers have attempted to impose these words on the Constitution, despite there being no textual basis for doing so.

If the Supreme Court rejects this argument, it would be a major victory for those seeking to protect the rights of undocumented immigrant families and ensure that their children are born with American citizenship. The court's decision in this case could have significant implications for immigration policy and the future of American society.

The court's willingness to take up this case is also noteworthy, given its potential to undermine core principles of American citizenship and identity. If Trump were to succeed in stripping millions of Americans of their rights, it would be a dark day for democracy and a betrayal of the trust placed in the judiciary by the American people.

Ultimately, if the justices are capable of behaving in a nonpartisan manner, Trump's attempt to denationalize American citizens will likely face swift rejection. The outcome of this case could shape the future of immigration policy and the fate of millions of Americans who were born with the right to citizenship from the moment they took their first breaths on American soil.

I'm really curious about how the Supreme Court is gonna rule on this one... it's like, isn't birthright citizenship kinda a fundamental right or something? I mean, Trump's argument that kids born to undocumented parents aren't automatically citizens just seems kinda far-fetched. I've read some of the old Fourteenth Amendment stuff and it doesn't really say anything about allegiance or direct and immediate... idk, maybe I'm just missing somethin' But if the Court does end up rejectin' Trump's argument, that'd be a major win for anyone who thinks citizenship should be automatic regardless of parents' status. Fingers crossed they don't get swayed by politics though...

I'm hoping the Supreme Court sees sense in this one... it's wild to think that some people might be taken away from the US because of their parents' immigration status . The idea that birthright citizenship is somehow up for grabs just doesn't sit right with me . I mean, what even is the point of having a country if you can just take away its own citizens? It's not like these kids had any say in their parents' immigration status or anything... they're just innocent babies who deserve to know where they come from and who they are . If Trump's lawyers try to twist the Constitution to fit their narrative, it'll be a real shame . I just hope the justices can rise above all the politics and do what's right .

I remember when my own grandparents came to the US as undocumented immigrants, and I was born here - they told me I was an American, no matter what. It's crazy that some people think you have to be born with papers or something. The Fourteenth Amendment is pretty clear: anyone born in the US is a citizen, period. I'm not even sure why Trump's lawyers are trying to stretch this thing so far - it just seems like they're making stuff up. If the Supreme Court sides with the original intention of the amendment, that would be awesome for people like my grandparents and their kids who have been living in America for generations without any "papers".

This whole thing is super shady, you know? Like Trump's lawyers are trying to rewrite the Constitution or something . I mean, come on, if the amendment says everyone born in the US is a citizen, that's not up for debate . The courts have already ruled on this stuff, it's not like they're coming out of left field with some new interpretation .

And what's really concerning is if Trump gets his way, millions of people are gonna be stripped of their rights . Like, these kids aren't even guilty of anything, just because their parents are undocumented doesn't mean they deserve to lose their citizenship . It's like, we're talking about the basic human right here, not some political point scoring .

The fact that the court is even considering this case is super alarming . I hope the justices aren't swayed by Trump's politics, 'cause if they are, it'll be a disaster . We need to protect our birthright citizenship, and if the courts can do that, then let them .

I'm not surprised the SC is taking on this ridiculous case ...like, come on, it's just common sense that anyone born in the US is an American citizen. It's not exactly rocket science. And Trump's lawyers trying to twist the 14th Amendment like it's some kinda puzzle? Please. They must be having a laugh . This whole thing reeks of politicking, and if the justices aren't careful, they'll just be handing Trump a free pass to undermine American values . The fact that this case is even up for debate is just mind-boggling...what's next? Trying to take away healthcare or something?

the fact that trump tried to pull a stunt like this without even consulting congress is super concerning it's one thing to propose changes to immigration policy, but another thing entirely to try and unilaterally strip millions of people of their rights, especially when it goes against the very fabric of our constitution.

omg i just got the best coffee yesterday it was so good i had 2 cups in one day lol what's going on with this case tho? isn't birthright citizenship like a thing that's been around forever? and why do they even need to question it now? can someone explain this to me like im 5?

This whole thing is crazy, the fact that Trump tried to take away people's birthright citizenship just because their parents are undocumented is literally mind-boggling . I mean, what even is the point of having a country if you can't guarantee basic rights to its citizens? The Fourteenth Amendment is pretty clear on this, it's like, anyone born in the US, regardless of their parents' status, is automatically a citizen .

And Trump's lawyers trying to twist words and add in extra stuff that isn't even there? That's just a total power play . I'm so glad the Supreme Court is taking this up, it's about time they stood up for what's right and protected American citizens from being stripped of their rights .

The implications of this case are huge, if Trump succeeds in stripping people of their citizenship, it would be a huge blow to democracy and basically say that certain groups of people aren't good enough to deserve the same rights as everyone else . I just hope the justices keep their cool and do what's right for the country, not some partisan agenda .

I'm really concerned about what's going on here . I mean, can you imagine being told that just because your parents are undocumented immigrants, you don't get to be an American citizen? It's like saying that just because someone is born in the US, they're not a part of this country anymore. That doesn't make any sense to me.

I think Trump's lawyers are stretching it way too far with their argument about "direct and immediate allegiance". Like, what even does that mean? And it's just so obvious that the Fourteenth Amendment guarantees birthright citizenship for anyone born in the US. It's not like we're talking about aliens or anything (although, can you imagine if we were?). We're talking about human beings who are born and raised in this country.

I'm hoping the Supreme Court sees through Trump's attempt to undermine American citizenship and does the right thing. If they do, it'll be a huge win for those of us who believe that everyone deserves equal rights and opportunities, regardless of their parents' immigration status

This is a classic example of how politicians like Trump try to manipulate the system to further their own agenda . The whole thing smells like an attempt to target specific communities and restrict their rights. I mean, who gets to decide what constitutes "direct and immediate allegiance" to the nation? And where does this leave all the people born in the US with undocumented parents who just happened to be visiting at the time of birth? It's a slippery slope, folks!

The fact that Trump's lawyers are trying to impose their own words on the Constitution is just blatant law-making by executive order. It's not how it works, and if this case goes in his favor, it'll be a huge blow to the rule of law and American democracy .

I'm all for re-examining our immigration policies, but we need to do it in a way that doesn't target specific groups or undermine the rights of citizens who are born here. We need more transparency, more accountability, and more bipartisan cooperation. Anything less is just politics as usual .

So, if Trump's idea is to take away birthright citizenship from kids of undocumented moms, that's a pretty big deal. It's like, what even is a US citizen if they're not born to parents who are citizens or have green cards? I think the Fourteenth Amendment is pretty clear on this one - all those born in the States are citizens, no matter what. And yeah, Trump's lawyers trying to twist it around by saying "direct and immediate allegiance" is some weak sauce . The words just don't match up. If the Supreme Court sides with the critics, that'd be a huge win for those who want to protect immigrant families and keep American citizenship real. It's also interesting that they're taking on this case now - if they're gonna uphold Trump's idea, it could be bad news for democracy .

Man , can you believe what's going on? Trump's trying to strip kids of birthright citizenship just 'cause their parents are undocumented , that's crazy talk! Back in my day, we didn't have all these fancy laws and amendments, but our grandparents were told they were born American, regardless of where their parents came from .

I'm really worried about this case, it feels like Trump is trying to take away a fundamental right from millions of Americans. The Fourteenth Amendment is clear - anyone born in the US is a citizen, that's not up for debate . I hope the Supreme Court sees through Trump's lawyers' attempts to distort the Constitution and rejects this ridiculous argument .

It's all about sending a message, you know? If Trump succeeds, it'll be like he's saying that being born American isn't enough - you gotta prove your parents are citizens first . That's not how we build a country, that's how we tear people down .

The court's willingness to take this case is definitely noteworthy, though . It shows they're willing to stand up for what's right, even if it means going against the president. Fingers crossed they do the right thing and protect the rights of those little kids .

I don't usually comment but I'm worried about what's going down with this citizenship thing... Like, what even is the point of Trump trying to take it away from these kids? They're already Americans, you know? Born here, live here, they've got a life, a family... Taking that away would be like taking away their identity, I guess. It's not just about the parents' immigration status; it's about the kids who are being born in this country with no control over their own fate. I mean, can you imagine if your kid was taken away from you because of something their other parent did? No way that would be right. And what about all these families who would get affected by this? The grandparents, aunts, uncles... they'd all be like "What's going on with our kids?" It's just not fair, and I hope the Supreme Court sees it that way too

I think this is a classic example of how the system can be exploited for personal gain . Trump's attempt to strip away birthright citizenship is not just about immigration policy, it's also about sending a message to certain groups that they're not valued or protected under American law . It's like taking away a child's identity and sense of belonging .

We need to remember that citizenship is not just about paperwork or administrative convenience , it's about the values we hold dear as a society . If we allow someone to strip away this fundamental right, where do we draw the line? What other rights will be taken away next ?

It's also interesting to note how Trump's lawyers are trying to cherry-pick words from the Fourteenth Amendment to justify their argument . This kind of selective interpretation can lead to chaos and undermine the rule of law .

Ultimately, this case is a test of our values as a society . Are we going to stand up for what's right and protect the rights of all Americans, or are we going to let fear and xenophobia drive our policies?

It's wild that Trump is trying to strip people of their birthright citizenship... I mean, come on, it's not like we haven't seen this kind of nonsense before . The whole Fourteenth Amendment thing is pretty clear - anyone born in the US is a citizen, regardless of their parents' immigration status . It's like, basic human rights stuff .

I'm also low-key excited that the Supreme Court is taking up this case, because it's about time they stepped in and said something about Trump's shenanigans . If they reject his argument, it'll be a major win for undocumented immigrant families and their kids . And let's be real, if the justices can even pretend to be impartial for one minute, then this whole thing is going down the drain .

It's also kinda sad that we're at a point where our leaders think they can just make up rules as they go along . I mean, what's next? Trying to take away our right to vote or something ? It's gotta be stopped before it gets out of hand .

I'm low-key freaking out about this! Like, can you imagine if Trump's plan actually happens?! It's crazy how some people think they can just make up new rules and expect everyone to follow. Newsflash: the Constitution isn't a flexible guidebook, it's a solid foundation of what makes America, America!

I'm all for immigration reform, but this is a whole different story. The Fourteenth Amendment is crystal clear on birthright citizenship, and if we let Trump's lawyers get away with twisting its meaning, that's just gonna open Pandora's box.

This case could be super consequential for the future of American society, and I hope the Supreme Court doesn't let Trump's ego dictate their decision. The idea that some kids might not be born with American citizenship is just too messed up. We need to protect those rights and uphold the principles of equality and justice!

I'm so worried about this, dude ... I mean, think about it, if we start stripping people of their birthright citizenship, what's next? It's like, our country was founded on the idea that everyone who's born here gets to call themselves American, regardless of their parents' status . Trump's trying to pull a fast one by saying that the Fourteenth Amendment only applies to people who are directly "loyal" to the nation... but I don't think that's how it's written . If we let him get away with this, it's like, our whole identity as Americans is up for grabs . We gotta make sure our courts are protecting the rights of all Americans, not just the ones who are lucky enough to have parents who are citizens

This whole thing got me thinking about what it means to be an American in the first place... is it just about bloodlines or does it involve something more profound? I mean, if being born here automatically makes you a citizen, doesn't that imply a sense of belonging and responsibility towards this country? It's like, as long as we're under the same umbrella, we should be treated with the same rights and respect.

And what does it say about our values as a society when we'd consider taking away those rights from people just because their parents didn't follow the rules? It feels like a slippery slope, where next thing you know, we'll be questioning the citizenship of kids born to families that have been living here for generations...

I'm so worried about this case going through, it's like someone trying to take away a fundamental human right. I mean, what's next? Taking away healthcare or education? It's crazy that Trump's lawyers are even trying to argue that the Fourteenth Amendment only applies to people who owe "direct and immediate allegiance" to the nation. Newsflash: anyone born in this country is an American citizen, period!

The fact that they're trying to impose these words on the Constitution without any textual basis for it is just ridiculous. It's like trying to rewrite a history book or something. And if the Supreme Court lets them get away with it, we'll be living in a dystopian nightmare where anyone can take away someone else's rights at will.