The question of what makes a good player great, and a great player the best, has been one that has puzzled me since 2014. I recall researching young talent at Rennes when Ousmane Dembélé was just beginning his journey to stardom.
Dembélé, born in 1997, possessed exceptional skills on the pitch, but what truly set him apart were qualities beyond football ability – resilience, adaptability, decision-making, creativity, work ethic, response to feedback and willingness to learn. These intangible traits were evident in his youth, and they only grew stronger with time.
When Thomas Tuchel, Dembélé's coach at Borussia Dortmund, spoke about the player's potential, he framed him into one of three categories: "aggressive-motivated", "binding-motivated", or "curious-motivated". Dembélé fell under the latter category – a quality that Tuchel prized in his players. This curious-motivated talent had the capacity to excel in any situation.
However, Dembélé's journey was not without its setbacks. His move to Barcelona, where he struggled with injuries and limited playing time, raised questions about whether he would fulfill his promise. The player's stock plummeted after a season of inconsistency, and it seemed as though he had wasted potential.
But something changed in 2025. Luis Enrique, Dembélé's manager at Paris Saint-Germain, discovered that liberating the player from pressure allowed him to flourish. With no expectations attached, Dembélé was able to start the press, dictate the tempo of games, and finish chances with ruthless efficiency.
This season has seen Dembélé become an integral part of PSG's success, and he has finally earned recognition for his abilities. The question remains: what makes a good player great? It is a complex equation that includes intangible qualities such as chemistry within a team, relationships with coaches, and playing systems that bring out the best in every player.
While we still cannot fully explain this phenomenon, Ousmane Dembélé's journey serves as proof that the qualities he possessed at 17 are still present today. His exceptional 2025 season, which has included decisive goals against Liverpool and Arsenal, is a testament to his growth and development as a player.
Dembélé's story offers a glimpse into what makes greatness in football – it is not solely about talent or skill, but also about the qualities that set players apart from one another. His well-deserved award serves as a reminder of these intangible traits that make a great player truly exceptional.
Dembélé, born in 1997, possessed exceptional skills on the pitch, but what truly set him apart were qualities beyond football ability – resilience, adaptability, decision-making, creativity, work ethic, response to feedback and willingness to learn. These intangible traits were evident in his youth, and they only grew stronger with time.
When Thomas Tuchel, Dembélé's coach at Borussia Dortmund, spoke about the player's potential, he framed him into one of three categories: "aggressive-motivated", "binding-motivated", or "curious-motivated". Dembélé fell under the latter category – a quality that Tuchel prized in his players. This curious-motivated talent had the capacity to excel in any situation.
However, Dembélé's journey was not without its setbacks. His move to Barcelona, where he struggled with injuries and limited playing time, raised questions about whether he would fulfill his promise. The player's stock plummeted after a season of inconsistency, and it seemed as though he had wasted potential.
But something changed in 2025. Luis Enrique, Dembélé's manager at Paris Saint-Germain, discovered that liberating the player from pressure allowed him to flourish. With no expectations attached, Dembélé was able to start the press, dictate the tempo of games, and finish chances with ruthless efficiency.
This season has seen Dembélé become an integral part of PSG's success, and he has finally earned recognition for his abilities. The question remains: what makes a good player great? It is a complex equation that includes intangible qualities such as chemistry within a team, relationships with coaches, and playing systems that bring out the best in every player.
While we still cannot fully explain this phenomenon, Ousmane Dembélé's journey serves as proof that the qualities he possessed at 17 are still present today. His exceptional 2025 season, which has included decisive goals against Liverpool and Arsenal, is a testament to his growth and development as a player.
Dembélé's story offers a glimpse into what makes greatness in football – it is not solely about talent or skill, but also about the qualities that set players apart from one another. His well-deserved award serves as a reminder of these intangible traits that make a great player truly exceptional.