Eagles' Hired Gun Sean Mannion Brings Uncertainty to the Line, but Change is Just What They Need.
The Philadelphia Eagles have finally secured a new offensive coordinator in Sean Mannion, ending a long and grueling search. The 35-year-old coach has an unorthodox resume - nine seasons as an NFL backup quarterback, followed by stints as a Packers' assistant coach before being promoted to quarterbacks coach in 2025.
While many will point out that Mannion's lack of experience calling plays is a major concern, others see it as an opportunity for the team. With the Eagles' offense in dire need of a shake-up, they're willing to take a chance on someone who has spent time playing the game's most high-pressure position.
Mannion's coaching influences are undoubtedly elite play-callers - Matt LaFleur, Sean McVay, and Kevin O'Connell have all had success with Mannion in various roles. And with Josh Grizzard on board as pass-game coordinator, there's a sense of philosophical alignment that could help the new offense gel.
However, it's also worth noting that Mannion has never led a full offensive room or called plays at any level. This lack of experience could be a major hurdle for him to overcome, especially given the scrutiny he'll face in the city of brotherly love.
Ultimately, this hire is a gamble - but one that might just pay off. The Eagles' offense was due for a change, and Mannion's unorthodox background brings an air of uncertainty that could be just what they need to shake things up.
Here are some key pros and cons to consider:
Pros:
- Change is coming: Mannion's coaching influences and tree are not the same as Nick Sirianni's. This means the Eagles' offense will be different, at least on paper.
- The pass game will take center stage: With Mannion's emphasis on play-action and under-center concepts, this could be an exciting direction for the team.
- He has help: Grizzard brings a wealth of experience to the table, which should help ease the transition.
- Elite play-callers are his coaching influences: McVay, LaFleur, and O'Connell have all had success with Mannion in various roles.
- The backup QB is often the best coach: Mannion's time playing quarterback could bode well for his ability to connect with players on offense.
Cons:
- He's never called plays: This lack of experience can't be overstated - most play-callers spend years honing their craft before taking on the role.
- He's never led an entire offensive room: Mannion has only spent one year leading the Packers' QB room, which could raise questions about his ability to command a full offense.
- He wasn't their first choice: The Eagles didn't get their top candidate for the job, and that's always a concern.
In the end, it's a dice roll. There are no guarantees when it comes to hiring coaches - see: Pete Carroll - so only time will tell if this move pays off or fizzles out. One thing is certain, though: change is coming to the Eagles' offense, and Mannion is at the helm.
The Philadelphia Eagles have finally secured a new offensive coordinator in Sean Mannion, ending a long and grueling search. The 35-year-old coach has an unorthodox resume - nine seasons as an NFL backup quarterback, followed by stints as a Packers' assistant coach before being promoted to quarterbacks coach in 2025.
While many will point out that Mannion's lack of experience calling plays is a major concern, others see it as an opportunity for the team. With the Eagles' offense in dire need of a shake-up, they're willing to take a chance on someone who has spent time playing the game's most high-pressure position.
Mannion's coaching influences are undoubtedly elite play-callers - Matt LaFleur, Sean McVay, and Kevin O'Connell have all had success with Mannion in various roles. And with Josh Grizzard on board as pass-game coordinator, there's a sense of philosophical alignment that could help the new offense gel.
However, it's also worth noting that Mannion has never led a full offensive room or called plays at any level. This lack of experience could be a major hurdle for him to overcome, especially given the scrutiny he'll face in the city of brotherly love.
Ultimately, this hire is a gamble - but one that might just pay off. The Eagles' offense was due for a change, and Mannion's unorthodox background brings an air of uncertainty that could be just what they need to shake things up.
Here are some key pros and cons to consider:
Pros:
- Change is coming: Mannion's coaching influences and tree are not the same as Nick Sirianni's. This means the Eagles' offense will be different, at least on paper.
- The pass game will take center stage: With Mannion's emphasis on play-action and under-center concepts, this could be an exciting direction for the team.
- He has help: Grizzard brings a wealth of experience to the table, which should help ease the transition.
- Elite play-callers are his coaching influences: McVay, LaFleur, and O'Connell have all had success with Mannion in various roles.
- The backup QB is often the best coach: Mannion's time playing quarterback could bode well for his ability to connect with players on offense.
Cons:
- He's never called plays: This lack of experience can't be overstated - most play-callers spend years honing their craft before taking on the role.
- He's never led an entire offensive room: Mannion has only spent one year leading the Packers' QB room, which could raise questions about his ability to command a full offense.
- He wasn't their first choice: The Eagles didn't get their top candidate for the job, and that's always a concern.
In the end, it's a dice roll. There are no guarantees when it comes to hiring coaches - see: Pete Carroll - so only time will tell if this move pays off or fizzles out. One thing is certain, though: change is coming to the Eagles' offense, and Mannion is at the helm.
. The fact that he has an unorthodox background playing QB could bring a fresh perspective to the team. I mean, who wouldn't want to shake things up after that lackluster season? 
It's also cool to see Josh Grizzard on board as pass-game coordinator - they might just click 
.
. I'm not sure how comfortable I am with the idea that he'll be learning on the fly without any prior experience. And what about his coaching style? Will it mesh well with the team's overall philosophy? 
. If anyone knows how to bring in some excitement to the offense, it's Mannion 
. Only time will tell if this gamble pays off or fizzles out 
.
itll be interesting 2 see how this all plays out but i gotta say, im kinda hyped 4 the pass game w/ grizzard on board 
. I think it's awesome that they're taking a chance on someone who's played the high-pressure position of backup QB in the NFL - he knows what works and what doesn't, you know? 
The fact that his coaching influences are all top-notch coaches like Matt LaFleur and Sean McVay is a major plus. It'll be interesting to see how he incorporates those philosophies into the Eagles' offense.
.
The pros definitely outweigh the cons for me - change is coming, and I'm here for it! 
. And what's up with Josh Grizzard being pass-game coordinator instead of actual OC? It seems like they're trying to ease Mannion into it without giving us any real insight into how things will play out 
. Not to mention, Mannion has never led an entire offense or even called plays at a high level... that's a big red flag for me 
gotta think mannion's the right dogg for this job 
