After years spent documenting state terror, I know it when I see it. And I see it now in the US and Israel | Janine di Giovanni

The Mask of Tyranny: How Democracies Are Silencing Dissent

In the name of security and order, democracies are adopting tactics once reserved for authoritarian regimes. I've spent years documenting state terror in countries like Syria, Iraq, and Egypt, and I know it when I see it - a deliberate disorientation of citizens at their most vulnerable, followed by agonizing torture. The testimonies from survivors haunt me still.

In the US and Israel today, I'm witnessing a disturbing shift towards this same brand of state terror. The tools are familiar, but the context is new: democracies operating in an "all-of-the-above" mode, where laws are technically above the law and institutions are disintegrating.

The justification for these actions - security, order, deterrence - sounds like a recipe for disaster. We've seen it before: the erosion of democratic norms, the rise of fear and intimidation, and the silencing of dissenting voices. The consequences are chilling: individuals internalizing fear, censoring their own thoughts, and wondering if the law will protect them when they're next targeted.

The true irony is that state terror does not make a democracy safer; it weakens them. By adopting the methods of tyrannies, democracies sacrifice the legitimacy that distinguishes them from authoritarian regimes.

We should be listening to the hundreds of testimonies I've collected over the years from those who have lived through state terror. The warning signals are clear: arbitrary detention, secret evidence, militarized policing, and the criminalization of dissent.

It's time for us to acknowledge the mask of tyranny that's being worn by democracies today. We must resist the temptation to justify policies that trample individual freedoms and erode the very foundations of democracy. The future of our societies depends on it.
 
omg this is sooo scary 🤯 i mean i know we need security but this kinda thing is not what we want as a democracy 😱 they're using tactics from dictators to control ppl now? no way! 💔 the fact that ppl are silencing themselves because of fear is just heartbreaking 😭 we gotta stand up against this & protect our rights 🤝
 
I'm getting this vibe from some of the US politicians lately 🤔... they're using "security" as a cop-out for their own agendas. Like, what's the real definition of security here? Is it just to keep themselves in power or is it about protecting actual citizens?

And can we talk about how weird it is that some of these same politicians are also super vocal about "free speech"? 🤷‍♂️ It feels like they're all for freedom when it serves them, but as soon as someone challenges their views or policies, suddenly they're all about restricting it.

I'm not buying the whole "national security" excuse. If they're so worried about security, why aren't they working on real issues that affect people's lives? It feels like a distraction tactic to me... 😒
 
I've been saying this for ages 🤷‍♂️, but I think some ppl are being way too harsh on the gov'ts here. They're not intentionally trying to turn into autoritarian regimes 🤯. It's all about security and maintaining order, right? 🚔 And yeah, we do need laws that protect us, but at what cost? 🤔 I mean, we've seen some crazy stuff go down in countries like Syria, Iraq, and Egypt... but is it really fair to say that our democracies are doing the same thing? 😐 Let's not jump to conclusions just yet 👀. We need to look closer at what's happening before we start calling out these gov'ts for being tyrannical 🤷‍♂️.
 
🤔 this article is giving me major vibes of the government trying to cover up their own dirty secrets... i've seen some weird stuff myself, like how they're always pushing for "national security" but it's always just an excuse to silence dissenting voices 🚫 and it's crazy how these tactics are being used in democracies now too... like, what's next? 🤯 we need to be keeping a closer eye on what's going down behind the scenes 👀
 
😔 I'm getting super worried about where we're headed as a society, you know? It feels like all these "security" measures are just being used as an excuse to chill free speech and stifle dissent. 🤐 Like, I get that safety is important, but at what cost? 🤑 We need to be careful not to trade our freedom for the sake of security, or we'll lose ourselves in the process. 👀 Let's listen to those who've been affected by state terror and take their warnings seriously - it could be us next! 😬
 
Back
Top